9 Comments

Honestly, I don't agree with either side on the Chinese balloon issue. America's current policy is undermining the Two China Solution, which is needlessly aggravating mainland China. China has the potential to be a powerful ally in the global fight against radical Islamic terrorism (as seen in Xinjiang).

Expand full comment

Thought this was a great analysis--hope you don't mind I gave you a shoutout! https://diplomacydebrief.substack.com/p/foreign-policy-and-bidens-state-of

Expand full comment

It seemed that China was playing a game of 'I'm not touching you' with the US. I wouldn't be surprised if another one floated by, given how pathetically this situation was handled.

Expand full comment

Hello,

I was amazed by how much attention this BALOON gained precisely because the U.S. officials made its presence public knowledge. This act alone would mean another "Smokescreen" operation in my mind.

The fact that even Random Minds have dedicated substantial time, talent, and passion to this "incident," however, made me pause.

I guess the reason for this hype is evident in this quote:

"I don't think that what China wants is a physical war. I don't think they are prepared for it. What they are looking to win is a war of ideas—a cultural war. And they want to outcompete with the U.S., destabilizing it, and kicking it off its throne as the world leader."

"To them, it's time for the East to reign and they are willing to send a few balloons to make it happen."

Yes, granted, Random Minds have the unwavering challenge to tackle any subject.

I am going to exercise mine and suggest a few things to consider.

CCP (a.k.a. China) doesn't give a spit about winning a war of ideas (which is not the same as a cultural war). The mere possibility of any doubt about China's (CCP) way will be the beginning of the end for the CCP.

Chinese way for millennia never was an obvious one. Of course, they DO NOT want "to outcompete with the U.S., destabilizing it, and kicking it off its throne as the world leader."

CCP wants to keep U.S. and any other "Western" competition thriving for as long as possible. Otherwise, who are they have to make their "Target practice"?

To any "normal" Chinese citizen, the East was, is and always be the true Realm. West only exist as the challenge to overcome. So, yes, they might be willing to send Balloons to the West to show how much of a challenge they perceive us.

Now, here is the real QUESTION: where is the proof that this Balloon was "Made in China"

I have quite the itch to put my bet on Russia using Chinese made balloon instead.

How about an even better one? The way this charade has played, maximum benefit would be gained by US/UK coalition by showing China "a finger" to encourage them further to dive into Russian misadventure in Ukraine

Expand full comment

A lot to tackle here, but I'll say that China does admit it's their balloon and I imagine the signal was possible to trace as well.

As for the idea you suggest that the U.S. made its presence public knowledge on purpose...that has crossed my mind too. There's something to it. Perhaps it is to garner public support for future actions since CCP will be seen as more of an enemy state to justify it. I did not include that thought as I had less of a basis to support it, but my gut says that might be true. Perhaps other readers have thoughts on your other points.

Expand full comment

Aren't you the Charmer?

I guess it worked!!

My point was actually to challenge you Quoted text.

Any response to that?

P.S. I am assuming this conversation is Private??

Expand full comment

P.P.S. have you seen the News Conference by Chinese MOF regarding US-UK-AU nuclear submarines alliance. I don't think that event would support "Made in China" thesis.

Expand full comment

The U.S. may have not shot the balloon down for the reason they gave: it had the equivalent of two busloads on it and having that fall on someone would be no bueno. Or they were studying it and what type of data it was sending back.

Here is a very good thread on the subject William "Balloon Guy" Kim.

https://twitter.com/TheKimulation/status/1544527308282896385?s=20&t=2DQB_iHVuYuRsMpxg0vzzA

Expand full comment