9 Comments
User's avatar
creon levit's avatar

A lot of people (including me) complain about "fact checkers". An organization that is actually doing something about it is the Society Library. They use curated argument mapping to exhaustively link claims, counterclaims, and references on controversial topics.

The idea that controversial and complex arguments can proceed in any other way (e.g. by outsourcing your opinion to an opaque and possibly incompetent or corrupt fact-checking authority) is counterproductive, to say the least.

The Society Library has in fact been hired by Poynter’s International Fact-Checking Network (mentioned in the article above) to create an educational curriculum for fact checkers.

See: https://societylibrary.medium.com/improving-fact-checking-by-improving-context-checking-93af262baac1

Expand full comment
Katherine Brodsky's avatar

I like the idea that they link to claims and counterclaims, I was thinking something along those lines might be a good way to approach the issue. I will check them out -- thank you for sharing!

Expand full comment
Josh's avatar

Most worrying is the complete shutdown of dissent. Even things once considered cold, hard, uncontested fact have been successfully shot down by a proper dissent. The fast and loose open-to-interpretation "fact checks" don't stand much of a chance.

Expand full comment
K. Foster's avatar

Well written article Katherine. Right now, I think many people are questioning the integrity of all fact checking media. Media in general.

Kathleen Foster

Expand full comment
Dave Rock's avatar

I think calmatters has some quality journalists and good ethics.

Expand full comment
Katherine Brodsky's avatar

I'll have to take a look, haven't checked that one out yet.

Expand full comment
alex glanz's avatar

Lately, I have to read a variety of sources, most of them non-American, to legitimize news of a geopolitical nature. Nobody respects mainstream media, be it online or print. Technical data or medical information is usually verifiable from larger university studies, but you again have to follow the funding. Words are plentiful, but truth and accuracy are a delicacy rarely enjoyed these days!

Expand full comment
Katherine Brodsky's avatar

You're taking the right approach—going for a variety of sources—though of course that's more time consuming. Hope we can find ways to bring the delicacy back. I think the more of an appetite there is, the more resources we will see.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 7, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Katherine Brodsky's avatar

I used to go to them to. It didn't feel quite so subjective at its start...

Expand full comment